Well, the recently released novelization for the movie confirms that he was, in fact, a clone!
In an excerpt from the book which has been doing the rounds online, Kylo Ren’s with Darth Vader’s former Master is described in detail. “All the vials were empty of liquid save one, which was nearly depleted. Kylo peered closer. He’d seen this apparatus before, too, when he’d studied the Clone Wars as a boy.”
“The liquid flowing into the living nightmare before him,” it continues, “was fighting a losing battle to sustain the Emperor’s putrid flesh.” The next paragraph adds that, “Kylo could feel in his very bones that this clone body sheltered the Emperor’s actual spirit. It was an imperfect vessel, though, unable to contain his immense power. It couldn’t last much longer.”
So, there you have it. The Palpatine we met in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker was the villain’s original spirit inside a cloned body that wasn’t strong enough to hold the evil within. If those Matt Smith rumours were correct, perhaps an earlier plan was to put him inside a much younger cloned body?
We may never know, but at least we now have one answer about the divisive release…
Check out some amazing concept art from Colin Trevorrow’s
Duel of the Fates by hitting the “Next” button below!

A disguised BB-8 infiltrates the First Order shipyard on a Kuat moon.
The orbital ring that delivers ore to the Kuat shipyard.
Stormtroopers walk among a migrant worker village on Kuat.
Rey, Finn, and Poe fight their way to the Eclipse Star Destroyer.
The crew detonates the orbital ring and steal an Eclipse Star Destroyer from the Kuat docking bay.
On Moraband, Wommels treat a near-death Kylo.
Leia at the Resistance base on Korilev.
Kylo gets a new mask.
With the Knights of Ren hot on their tail, Poe pushes the Falcon into lightspeed and crashes it into the ice planet of Wavett.
The crew, stranded on Wavett, sit around a campfire.
The docking array on Bonadan.
Razer Sails docked on Bonadan.
“Chewie grabs this Knight of Ren, throws him into the air, and shoots him out of the sky like a clay pigeon.”
Kylo approaches the Sith temple on Remnicore.
Kylo and his droid navigate Remnicore.
Kylo sucks the life force from a tree.
New Resistance ship.
Finn is captured and imprisoned in a work camp on Coruscant.
TIE fighters chase the Falcon through the Coruscant citadel.
BB-8 flees from oncoming fire.
Stormtroopers fight against Coruscant citizens.
Kylo inside a cave on Remnicore, as Tor Valum describes it, a “vergence in the force”
Rey gazes at the temple of Mortis.
Rey and Kylo face off at the peak of the temple of Mortis.
“Finn reads a story to the young kids and they ask if they really think Rey is gone. Finn believes she’s alive because of the force. Poe and Chewie are flying and they find a beacon on a planet. Rey is alive, on the Wavett planet, pulling the Falcon out of the icy water.”
On Modesta, BB-8 sees a familiar face.
Rey arrives to train a new generation of Jedi.
Powered by WPeMatico